How should a ‘Killer’ RSS News/Feed Reader be like…

Recently there was a mail floating around in one of the groups in my office. It was about how does one manage to tackle the information overload. I thought I could add something I do and I want in my ‘perfect’ or to say ‘Killer’ RSS Feed reader for me.

1. Be Online, Simple UX, Shared feeds of own & friends, Favorite feeds, Search … :

Here, in simple terms, I’m just mentioning the features of Google Reader (I know you guessed it correctly!) – it’s simple, less cluttered – best of all it’s online which enables me to access the feeds anytime anywhere. I also like the ‘Shared Feeds’ with which I’m able to share the feeds I find is interesting with all my friends; Of course other features like one-click favorite of items, search are also very good – above all, it’s free as well . But I hate it when it bloats my browser’s memory foot print. I feel online feed readers have clear advantage in this category, at least for me.

There are few new feed readers coming up on the ‘cloud’ (simply as hosted applications). But it’ll take some time for a new one to replace Google Reader for me. I also like if instead of ‘only web’ if the feed reader on both ‘desktop+web’ is better (something like mesh).

I guess most readers will choose Google Reader as their favorite, but still I got to ask here: Do you use any other feed reader apart from Google Reader (be it desktop or on the cloud). Netvibes, PageFlakes, Newsgator or just your iGoogle

2. A good RSS Ranking/ Rating system on top of it:

I like AideRss and the Firefox plug-in for Google Reader that is available. When I’m in a hurry, I really just go ahead and read only the top feeds which AideRss shows me as the ‘Best’.

But I do realize ranking the feeds at ‘real time’ is quite complex and always challenging and it works best for feeds that are at least little older. There is lot of opportunities to improvise in this front. Looking at the milestones of AideRss, I’m hoping for better ranking of the feeds.

Do you use any other feed ranking systems that you feel is good?

Update 10/17: Melanie from AideRSS has commented about the improvement made to AideRss.

3. When I read news, I like the way Newspapers do it….

I came across GreatNews RSS reader quite sometime back – the one thing I like the best about it is it’s Full page reading style which makes me to ‘read all feeds in a glimpse’ – Like a newspaper. Like it right? (I know it is a desktop reader – I keep switching between GReader & GreateNews once in a while. 🙂 )

Among other features in GreatNews, I like labeling, channel statistics, new items highlight, search – which are very basic but are important too.

The River of News Approach: There is a another better way of displaying news in a reader ‘River of News’ (by Dave Winer) – which improves ‘the reading experience’ (I felt is GreatNews also tries to achieve the same in another approach). But the some of the sample implementations of River of News didn’t satisfy (or impress) me – displaying the feeds as a huge list (river) of links with small description doesn’t make my reading better & definitely doesn’t give a news paper like feel.

I’m not saying the approach is flawed. Also even GreatNews sports the ‘Folder-by-Folder’ view only which again is painful to read one by one.

My preferred way of reading, call it ‘My News’: I’d like it better this way: All my top news(feeds) on page1, my tech news on page 2, personal feeds on page 3, sports on page 4, astronomy on 5, … – all listing ‘top ranked’ news items in neatly laid out way. This is just logical grouping of my feeds in different categories’. GreatNews has a very good start here. All it needs is a good ranking system being integrated to it.

I’d have the ‘River of News’ as my Second best liked way of reading feeds (and third method being the folder-by-folder view 😛 ) This way, once the ‘My News’ is reading is done, I switch to ‘the River view’ and then later to the remaining news if I really have time to spend on.

4. An IM bot – to just keep me updated at troubled times…

I don’t like to keep my feed reader always open, but I do have my Instant Messenger sign-in all time. So, an IM bot for all my top feeds will try to fulfill my hunger for the information & free me from the ‘information overload’ at least when I’m into serious office work.

There are lots of RSS IM Bots presently available, I use iNezha (Anothr) bot to stream my top ranked (feeds that AideRss categorizes as ‘Best’) to my IM.

On a final note,

  1. I didn’t mention about the mobile version of all this because given the popularity and potential opportunities available in mobile apps, it is just trivial that all the above features should be available in the mobile version of the ‘killer’ feed reader. 🙂
  2. There are separate breed of blog aggregators: fine example being Techmeme – These are public feed aggregators but might directly influence one’s reading habits. I know people who wake up to read Techmeme .
  3. and, this post contains references to different tools and methods how I presently manage my feeds. But every other tool/ technology is still in growing stage, so you might find it limiting – whenever you think your favourite tool is lacking something, do note it down somewhere to add it here as comment.
  4. I’m not really sure if I’ll be creating such a reader immediately. Need to think about it.
  5. Here we explored how to manage feeds. There are whole different and huge source of information:
    1. Email subscriptions – via Groups of Y!, MSN, G
    2. Social network participation
    3. Bookmarks & Sharing (delicious), etc – I guess each would deserve it’s own blog post!

What do you think about this? Don’t forget to Comment/ Criticize/ Share this!

Spread the knowledge! Share this post!!:

6 Responses to How should a ‘Killer’ RSS News/Feed Reader be like…

  1. Hi Praveen — thanks for including us!

    The timeliness question is an ongoing one, and certainly one that’s always in the back of our minds (and for which we’re always open to suggestions).

    The fundamental issue is, of course, that we base our analysis on engagement, and engagement doesn’t magically spring up the second a publisher posts something new — takes a bit of time to percolate out into the net, get comments, appear in RSS readers, spark blog posts, bookmarks, tweets, etc.

    We find that within about four hours you can get a fairly accurate engagement score. For people who need/want real-time, however, that’s just about forever.

    We’ve noodled on “predictive” rankings a bit, too, but have had far more people against the idea (asking that we stick with hard data) than for it, so it’s not something we plan to get into.

  2. Praveen says:

    @Melanie Nice to know the progress & improvements of AideRSS. and, Thanks for agreeing on the post. I’ll try to help you out with my comments soon… 🙂

  3. I use igoogle. Google reader hasn’t attracted me at all… I think it’s the interface – it kind of bores me and I can’t get motivated to even figure it out. I am def at the point where I won’t waste time with web apps that I find boring, clunky etc right off the bat, because I know well enough there’s another one somewhere that won’t be so ‘difficult’ as well as the fact that we will all be ‘in the clouds’ within a few years – maybe longer but what’s the diff. ie- non local web apps and even hardware. do you agree (at all?) I wanted to send a screen shot of my igoogle setup to demonstrate what I mean – I have numerous tabs (categorizing my feeds) and I can filter them all the time – ditch things that aren’t working out etc… I find the interface to be totally eficacious, esthetically pleasing, and I just plain love it. It is like the natural extention to bookmarks. On that note, I also find online bookmark things like technorati or whatever to be boring. Anyway, I am researching the idea of bookmarks vs feeds and should be on my way – I’m trying to envision where this feed interface business is going to land – I have a feeling that the feeds will eventually include audio video capabilities so that you can quickly go to any feed in your feed reader and see/hear a quick jolt of what’s up… ciao – best Brielle

  4. Praveen says:

    @Briele Thanks for the comment.
    It is interesting that how you manage reading updates from all your favourite websites!
    But, under-the-hood google reader is just another Ajax-based-auto-updating webpage with ‘feeds’ arranged in tabbed interface getting updated periodically, which is almost similar to parts of iGoogle that you mentioned. But obviously an app will do things better for what it is designed to do, and that’s where I feel there should be a ‘killer’ feed/news reader! (do you agree?)
    It’s true that there is no silver bullet when it comes to technology and not one solution suit everyone’s taste and hence the plethora of other RSS feed readers exists (

    As you mentioned, moving to ‘the cloud’ might make our life more simpler and ‘lighter’ but will take it’s own time.
    Comparing Bookmarks vs Feeds – I’d simply say both are meant for two different purposes: feeds – to keep getting the updates and bookmarks – to cherish the favourite page. I’m interested in the findings from your study. Do blog about it.

    and, yes feeds are already capable of including rich media contents – it depends on the feed reader’s capability to display that content in proper format – end of day feeds are just data wrapped in xml 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: